Round 4: A clear leader, and the ultimate chess hatred


22-Feb-2011 01:04, NIKON CORPORATION NIKON D90, 4.0, 29.0mm, 0.077 sec, ISO 3200


After four rounds the Batavia tournament as a clear leader. GM Gerald Hertneck, who one day before the first round didn’t know that he was going to play a chess tournament, is on 3.5/4. The chances that a GM norm will be scored in this tournament are small, but not impossible; IMs Bart Michiels and Christov Kleijn share second place with 2.5 points. Meanwhile, IM Merijn van Delft experienced the typical, gruelling chess hatred that only chess players can fully grasp – no chance to explain it to someone who doesn’t play the game.

Just like in the previous round, one of the five games was over very quickly. This time it wasn’t a peaceful affair, no, it was a game that can only be described as a slaughter. Manuel Bosboom played the black pieces for the third time, and yet again his opening moves fell into the don’t-try-this-at-home category. Perhaps even more worrisome is that Manuel might repeat it once more: “It wasn’t so bad. My 5… b4 was probably too early. I should have played 5… d6 and maybe he has to go 6. h3 then,” he said afterwards.


22-Feb-2011 02:11, NIKON CORPORATION NIKON D90, 5.6, 29.0mm, 0.017 sec, ISO 3200


The author of this report thinks back with nostalgia to the times when Bosboom defeated GMs on the black side in the Sicilian Scheveningen main line. These days the difference of his play with White and Black is a difference of day and night…

1. e4 c6 2. d4 g6 3. Nc3 b5 4. Nf3 Bg7 5. Bd3 b4? 6. Ne2 a5 7. a3! Na6 8. Bd2 Qb6 9. O-O d6

10. c3! Nf6 11. e5 dxe5 12. Nxe5 O-O 13. Qa4 (Here Black cannot avoid the loss of a pawn, according to Kleijn.) 13… c5 14. axb4 cxd4 15. Qxa5 Qb7 16. Nxd4 Nc7 17. Qc5 Nfd5 18. Nec6 e5 19. Nb3 Nf4 20. Be4 Rxa1 21. Rxa1 1-0

The next game to finish was Robert Ris vs Praveen Thipsay. The Dutch IM played an excellent game, outplaying his Indian opponent from the start. “He reacted not very well to my h3 King’s Indian. It was the first time I played this, but I know quite a lot of it because of my work for ChessVibes Openings and I studied many games of the expert in this line, Polish GM Michal Krasenkow.”

1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 g6 3. Nc3 Bg7 4. e4 d6 5. Nf3 O-O 6. h3!?

Here, in the latest issue of ChessVibes Openings (published last Wednesday), Ris explains that after 6…e5 7.d5 “Black can chose between the concrete 7…Nh5!? and the strategically sound 7…a5.” However, Thipsay went for 6… Na6 7. Bg5 c6?! (Black might still be able to return to the main line with 7… Qe8) 8. Be2 e5 9. d5 h6 10. Be3 Nc5 11. Nd2! a5 12. g4! Bd7 13. h4! and White got the nice edge he was looking for when playing 6.h3.


18-Feb-2011 21:06, NIKON CORPORATION NIKON D90, 4.8, 60.0mm, 0.025 sec, ISO 3200


Desperately trying to find counter-play Thipsay then sacrificed pawns on b5 and d6, but Ris just took them. The Dutchman only had to solve one more issue: what to do with the king?

24. Kf2!? Bh4+ 25. Kg2 Qf6 26. Rh2 g5 27. Rg1 g4 28. Kh1 and White won.

Top seed Gerald Hertneck won again, increasing his lead in the standings to a full point. His victim was Dutch IM Benjamin Bok, who didn’t go down without a fight. Hertneck: “It was a very difficult game. He sacrificed a pawn and got some play, but it wasn’t easy. After move 40 I was definitely better.”

Probably here things went wrong for White. 36. f3 looks quite OK, e.g. 36… Qe6 (36… h5 37. Rd6!?) 37. Ng4 h5 38. Nxf6 Qxf6 39. e5 Qf5 40. Rd6. Instead, it went 36. e5? Ne4 37. Qb2 Qe6 38. f3 Ng5 39. f4

39… a3! 40. Qe2 Ne4 41. Rd3 a2 42. Kf3 Rxd3 43. Qxd3 f5 and Black won.


22-Feb-2011 01:07, NIKON CORPORATION NIKON D90, 5.0, 22.0mm, 0.04 sec, ISO 3200


Robin van Kampen and Bart Michiels played what you can call a “correct draw”. In a French Tarrasch the two followed theory for a long time.

“Here I was hoping for 17… Rf5? which has more or less been refuted. But he went for the correct 17… Rf8. After that I was just shuffling the pieces a bit, until we reached this IQP position which isn’t really an IQP position,” said Van Kampen.

(For anyone who just went “what the hell is he talking about?” we’ll write out that abbreviation: Isolated Queen’s Pawn.) “The important difference with those textbook examples,” Van Kampen explained, “is that there’s no white pawn on e3. This means it’s a real passed pawn, and besides, there’s never the idea of doubling on the d-file and then winning the pawn with e3-e4. So White is not really better.” Instructive stuff!


22-Feb-2011 01:04, NIKON CORPORATION NIKON D90, 4.0, 26.0mm, 0.2 sec, ISO 3200


Merijn van Delft had a very disappointing afternoon against grandmaster Niaz Murshed, who played the “Fort Knox” variation of the French. This line is called after the famous prison in Kentucky, USA. The reason? Well, Black is more or less putting up a fortress right from the opening and then sits and waits, saying “Come and try to get in, you won’t succeed.”

The strategy involves Black exchanging one of his bishops for a knight at an early stage, which for very classical players is enough reason to play for a win against this opening. Van Delft is quite a classical player, and did want to win, for which he deserves credit. But the way he did it was just a blunder.

“My position was so good that it was still a draw after 39.g4?. But my c4-c5 was a ridicoulous move.” (Van Delft) This happened after 28… Nxg4 30. Rd8 Nf6 31. Qxh5 Nxh5 32. Be3 Rxd8 33. Rxd8+ Kh7 34. Rd7 Bf8 35. Rxe7 Bxe7 36. Bc8 Bxa3 37. Bb6 Bb4

38. c5? (38. Bxb7 c5 39. Bc7 Kg7 40. Kg2 Kf6 41. Kf3 should hold.) 38… Nf4! 39. Bxb7 Ne2+ 40. Kf1 Nd4 and the white bishops cannot move anywhere and his king is also locked up.

Final position

“It was a horrible feeling. You start calculating, and realize that all options fail for White. Then you reach a sudden calmness, and realize that it is all over,” said Van Delft, who stayed in the Batavia cafe until closing time. He felt the ultimate chess hatred for the rest of the evening and probably beyond.


22-Feb-2011 00:54, NIKON CORPORATION NIKON D90, 4.0, 29.0mm, 0.125 sec, ISO 3200


See also Tom Bottema’s reports at


Round 4: A clear leader, and the ultimate chess hatred — 1 Comment

  1. Fort Knox is oorspronkelijk een legerfort, maar vooral bekend als opslagplaats van alle amerikaanse goudreserves. Het is nooit een gevangenis geweest.
    Leuk verslag van het toernooi.